Red tide remnants: Where do dead fish end up?

5I5GEBN4W5H5LE57KQLVK7U5OIBiologists perform a necropsy on a whale shark that died in Florida waters. MUST CREDIT: Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission

By Larry Barszewski Contact ReporterSouth Florida Sun Sentinel

Red tide’s stinky situation: What to do with all the fish carcasses that wash ashore?

The decision in South Florida, which began experiencing the effects of red tide two weeks ago, has been to put them in landfills where they can rest in [smelly] pieces.




WFTS Webteam Photo

The solution seemed fine, since landfills aren’t known for their pleasant aromas, but there were still concerns the fish stench might be a bit too much even at a dump.

Broward Commissioner Mark Bogen didn’t want any residents complaining about a fishy smell coming from the landfill commonly known as Mount Trashmore in Coconut Creek in his district.

Officials say they got Waste Management to agree that any more fish brought to the landfill near Florida’s Turnpike will be taken to another one in Okeechobee as their final resting place.

Clean-up crews are double-bagging the fish, too, in Broward County, to prevent leakage and curb any smells.

And the carcasses in Palm Beach County have to be brought directly to the landfill and not dropped off at a transfer station, said Willie Puz, spokesman for the county’s Solid Waste Authority that operates a landfill near West Palm Beach.

Landfill crews in Palm Beach and Broward counties waste no time burying the carcasses as soon as they arrive, rather than waiting until the end of the day as is done with most other garbage.

“With this waste, we’ll dig a separate hole and cover it immediately,” said Waste Management spokeswoman Dawn McCormick.

But maybe there’s too much of a stink being raised about the potential foul smell.

Lois Rose is the solid waste operations manager for Sarasota County, which has taken in several hundred tons of dead fish due to red tide over the past two months. She said even that large amount isn’t significant enough to create an unbearable stench.

“It smells like dead fish,” Rose said, but is only a small part of the 1,100 tons of garbage that arrive at the landfill daily.

“Yes, the girls and the staff at the scales will say ‘Yes, we have dead fish coming in,’” but it doesn’t make the overall site smell, Rose said. “It’s just like any other day, like when we get a load of dead fish coming in from the fish market or the pier.”

The amount of dead fish that have shown up on Florida’s east coast is minuscule in comparison.

The Palm Beach County landfill estimates it has received one ton of fish related to red tide, Puz said.

Dead fish are seen washed ashore at the Ocean Inlet Park in Ocean Ridge, Fla., Thursday, Oct. 4, 2018. Officials have confirmed that red tide has appeared on Florida’s Atlantic Coast. (Joe Cavaretta / South Florida Sun Sentinel)

Waste Management originally told Broward County it could handle up to 40 tons a day of fish at its Coconut Creek landfill, but the actual amount taken there has been far less: two loads totaling 500 pounds from Fort Lauderdale were buried there, McCormick said, prior to the new arrangement to send out the carcasses to Okeechobee.

McCormick had no reports of any additional loads being brought to Monarch Hill.

Where the fish go depend on where the cities have disposal contracts.

In Hollywood, for instance, where up to 1,700 fish washed up recently, the city uses Waste Connections. City officials said the company will be transporting the carcasses to a landfill in Central Florida.



“I had really, really bad bleeding ulcers to the point where I was actually blacking out,” she says. “So I go to my doctor. The first thing he tells me is, ‘Contaminated water. How’s your drinking water?’ “


This image is 19 YEARS OLD!!


As President Trump promises major investment in infrastructure, people across the country are hoping that includes spending on water pipes for drinking.

Flint, Mich., was a high-profile example of the many communities — like one in Eastern Kentucky — where people just can’t trust their water.

In Martin County, Ky., the water intake pulls from a river heavily contaminated by sewage and years of coal and gas extraction.

Josie Delong, a resident of the county, says she used to drink tap water until a doctor told her it could be the cause of her health issues.

“I had really, really bad bleeding ulcers to the point where I was actually blacking out,” she says. “So I go to my doctor. The first thing he tells me is, ‘Contaminated water. How’s your drinking water?’ ”

Now, she says she does all she can to avoid drinking from the tap. She even puts bottled water in her children’s bathroom when they brush their teeth.

The county water treatment plant needs serious upgrades, and the distribution pipes are so leaky that they lose more water than they deliver.

On cold winter nights, when customers leave their taps running to keep their pipes from freezing, the water district would cut the water off. If not, the tanks wouldn’t refill, and there wouldn’t be enough water to flush toilets.

But when cut off, there’s no pressure in the pipes, and filth can seep through the cracks. When the system is once again turned on, the water can be brown or black and very smelly.

At a public meeting last year, Joe Hammond of the county water district faced a crowd that was angry about the lack of warning before the cut-offs.

The Martin County water district is under state investigation for the third time since 2002. When they find a leaky pipe, Hammond says all they can do is patch it up.

“You’ve got a little hole there already — it’s going to get bigger,” he says. “We just don’t have the money to replace it with right now.”

Though the county has produced millions of dollars in coal and gas, little of the wealth has been invested in the water system. As the local coal industry has continued to decline, it’s only become more difficult to find money for infrastructure investments.

Scott Pruitt, the new head of the Environmental Protection Agency, says water infrastructure is a priority. But Gail Brion of the University of Kentucky, who has worked on water treatment issues for decades, is skeptical.

She says she worries water pipes can’t compete with more visible projects like roads and bridges.

“What you’re seeing is a long history of non-investment that’s now starting to cause long-term problems, but it’s not flashy,” she says. “That’s one of the problems with drinking water is that it’s underground — it’s hidden.”

State and local officials say they’ll be looking out for any federal spending that could help rebuild trust in the county’s tap water. The cost of rebuilding the system is estimated at $13.5 million.

Benny Becker reports for the public radio collaborative Ohio Valley ReSource.

Trump signs resolution to permit dumping mining waste into waterways

Screen Shot 2018-10-07 at 10.05.14 AM.pngTo use interactive map:,25.6735,-76.436,50.9807

So as we hare having a difficult time with mining waste in drinking water (see post 10.7.18)…


Link to video:

‘You Just Don’t Touch That Tap Water Unless Absolutely Necessary’

2018-08-30-martin-county-water--rfacun-_0221_slide-a80b1035543a75483b1c682ea6d69699a6cff683-s1300-c85.jpgRockcastle Creek flows past residential homes and businesses along Route 3 in the town of Inez, the county seat of Martin County, Ky. A giant coal sludge spill in October 2000 contaminated the county’s rivers for miles, and locals still don’t trust the water.     Rich-Joseph Facun for NPR

Aleigha Sloan can’t remember ever drinking a glass of water from the tap at her home.

That is “absolutely dangerous,” the 17-year-old says, wrinkling her nose and making a face at the thought.

“You just don’t touch that tap water unless absolutely necessary. I mean, like showers and things — you have to do what you have to do. But other than that, no,” she says. “I don’t know anybody that does.”

Sloan sits on the couch in her family’s cozy two-story house, tucked back along winding rural roads in Huntleyville, Ky., near the West Virginia border. Her mother, BarbiAnn Maynard, 41, is in the kitchen, emptying out a plastic 5-gallon jug that she uses to fetch cooking water from a local spring.

“You take it for granted until you don’t have it,” Maynard says about a clean water supply. “I think that’s the attitude of a lot people right now, but I don’t think they understand how close they are to it happening to them.”

img_60591_slide-f793aa2a94abc0719b6242013d0a297b1248e18e-s700-c85.jpgBarbiAnn Maynard walks between the headstones at her family’s cemetery, pointing out her grandparents and her cousins. Her deep roots in Martin County are one reason she says she’ll never leave, despite the lack of a reliable supply of clean drinking water.Kat Lonsdorf/NPR

Americans across the country, from Maynard’s home in rural Appalachia to urban areas like Flint, Mich., or Compton, Calif., are facing a lack of clean, reliable drinking water. At the heart of the problem is a water system in crisis: aging, crumbling infrastructure and a lack of funds to pay for upgrading it.

On top of that, about 50 percent of water utilities — serving about 12 percent of the population — are privately owned. This complicated mix of public and private ownership often confounds efforts to mandate improvements or levy penalties, even if customers complain of poor water quality or mismanagement.

Drinking water is delivered nationally via 1 million miles of pipes, many of which were laid in the early to mid-20th century, according to the American Society of Civil Engineers. Those pipes are now nearing the end of their life spans.

A 2017 report by the group gave America’s water systems a near-failing grade, citing an estimated 240,000 water line breaks a year nationwide.

The Environmental Protection Agency estimates it will cost the country nearly $400 billion to fix the problem — a burden that would fall largely on average ratepayers who often don’t have the extra money. It’s a particularly heavy burden in places like Martin County, one of the poorest counties in the country.

The nearly 12,000 residents in Martin County have to deal with tap water that sometimes comes out brown or milky or smells bad. Other times the water is shut off and nothing comes out of the taps at all. At the Martin County Water Warriors Facebook page, people post videos of their water, share boil water advisory notices or try to figure out how widespread an outage is.

All of this is why Maynard’s family doesn’t drink the tap water. She says they spend about $30 a week on bottles of drinking water. That’s on top of their monthly water bill — about $65 — for water used only for cleaning and flushing the toilets.

Some county residents say they bathe their babies in bottled water to avoid exposing them to the tap water; others store jugs of water near the bathroom in case the tap runs dry in the middle of a shower.

“It’s anything other than normal,” Maynard sighs. “But it’s our normal.”

ap_00102301331_slide-bd5168f169a90ee27b26869ac4546d5947348044-s1300-c85.jpgIn October 2000, an estimated 300 million gallons of toxic waste — including heavy metals like arsenic and mercury — flowed into Martin County’s river system. Here, the remains of a coal sediment pond that collapsed near Inez.    Bob Bird/AP

The decades-long problems in Martin County illustrate just how complex the issues are. Leaks in the pipes that carry water throughout the county result in substantial losses of treated water — nearly 65 percent in 2016. And those leaks create a vacuum, sucking in untreated water from the ground that’s subsequently delivered to people’s homes.

That’s especially worrisome given the region’s history of mining and industrial activities. In October 2000, a giant coal sludge spilldumped more than 300 million gallons of toxic waste — including heavy metals like arsenic and mercury — into Martin County’s river system, which is also its main source for drinking water. Thick black sludge ran downstream for dozens of miles, spilling over onto lawns and roads.

And even after officials announced that the water was safe, the trauma from that spill created mistrust that runs deep to this day.

2018-08-30-martin-county-water--rfacun-_025_slide-f089c50ed9ad14cf0d2c77e5cf42c953b8988923-s700-c85.jpgGary Michael Hunt is one of Martin County’s nearly 12,000 residents living with water issues. Hunt lives outside town on a mountain ridge and has outfitted a tank to collect water when the taps work and store it for when they stop working. He says his taps run dry multiple times a week.  Rich-Joseph Facun for NPR

That concern is warranted, says Gail Brion, a University of Kentucky professor of civil engineering specializing in water infrastructure.

“The treatment plant operators can’t control the quality of the water in the pipes if they cannot keep the pipes intact,” Brion says. “This is really not on the water quality coming out of the plant. It is on what happens to the water as it goes through this leaky straw.”

The Martin County Water District, the private utility that manages the county’s water, reported 29 line breaks in 2017 and advised residents to boil their water in case of contamination. There have been a slew of other infrastructure-related issues — like failing intake pumps struggling to fill the reservoir.

The utility spent hundreds of thousands of dollars in September to rent a pump in hopes of fixing the problem, but it wasn’t enough. The water level has gotten so low that the utility board recently declared a state of emergency, warning that the system was near collapse. There’s a real chance the county could run out of water.

Reporting by the local paper, the Mountain Citizen, prompted the first state investigation into the Martin County Water District, in 2002. Since then, there have been several audits and investigations by the Public Service Commission, the agency that regulates utilities in the state.

Its recommendations have ranged from basic maintenance improvements to better money management to improved water testing — and were mostly not implemented. Since the Martin County Water District is privately owned, it falls largely outside state jurisdiction: Aside from investigations, recommendations and fines, there’s little that state governing bodies can do.

2018-08-30-martin-county-water--rfacun-_0131_slide-abde72d95e3ce06f01561da2b4f18658d6d40b7e-s1300-c85.jpgGary Ball, editor of the local Mountain Citizen newspaper, has been reporting on water issues in the county for nearly two decades. Reporting in the Mountain Citizen prompted the state in 2002 to open the first investigation into the Martin County Water District.  Rich-Joseph Facun for NPR

In 2016, the Public Service Commission opened another investigation, which is ongoing. Galvanized by the 2000 coal sludge spill, retired public school teacher Nina McCoy, 61, is one of the most vocal water activists in Martin County. She goes to nearly every meeting related to water issues in the county, sometimes spending all day driving to and from Frankfort, the state capital, to attend hearings.

This time around, Mary Cromer, a lawyer from the Appalachian Citizens’ Law Center, has stepped in to represent the citizens of Martin County pro bono. She travels regularly to the county seat, Inez, where McCoy lives, to help organize local residents.

The region’s century-long reliance on the coal industry is one issue, Cromer says, but not the only one.

“This isn’t just confined to Martin County. This isn’t just confined to Appalachia. We have dilapidated infrastructure all over this country,” she says. “And so if you’re going to have rural areas that are going to survive, much less thrive, you’ve got to pay attention to these critical infrastructure needs.”

2018-08-30-martin-county-water--rfacun-_0051_slide-9fb190e1a9cd4b9a005fec9bb15d9bfde554aa38-s1300-c85.jpgNina McCoy, a retired biology teacher, at Metrobilly’s, the local diner she runs with her husband. They use bottled water in their cooking. McCoy started the Martin County Concerned Citizens group to address local water issues. Rich-Joseph Facun for NPR

Change is happening in Martin County, albeit slowly. The state attorney general announced in June that his office would be opening an independent investigation into the water utility, specifically focused on alleged money mismanagement. Most of the Martin County Water District board resigned at the beginning of the year, and new leadership was brought in to help right the system.

But the fixes all require money, and the utility is more than $1 million in debt — and it will need millions of dollars to upgrade the system. That’s money Martin County simply doesn’t have.

2018-08-30-martin-county-water--rfacun-_051_slide-4e246072af3ae04ecf34d4dd6e1b00b4107b17da-s1300-c85Mickey McCoy (from left), a local activist and Nina’s huband; Ricki Draper, a fellow with the Appalachian Citizens’ Law Center; Mary Cromer, a staff attorney with the law center; and Nina McCoy meet in August to discuss water issues in Martin County.   Rich-Joseph Facun for NPR

Jimmy Kerr, the board’s new treasurer, took on the position because he wants to make the county better for his two daughters, but he says it is a daunting task.

“If we don’t get our finances in order, we will never be able to give the people of Martin County the water that they want,” Kerr says.

The Martin County Water District recently received nearly $5 million in federal grant money, but it’s not enough. Now it’s looking to raise rates dramatically, something that — aside from some temporary rate hikes to cope with emergency situations — hasn’t happened in years. The utility has asked for a nearly 50 percent permanent rate increase, which has left a lot of residents angry.

“I know who I’m hurting. But there’s no one coming in on a white horse to save us,” Kerr says. “The people of this county did not create this mess, but we’re the ones who are going to have to fix it.”

2018-08-30-martin-county-water--rfacun-_032_slide-0be6e2468234981de6681c6899ab30d71c3de473-s700-c85Jimmy Kerr is treasurer of the Martin County water board. One of his main reasons for taking on the role was an effort to help improve the water issues for his children.  Rich-Joseph Facun for NPR

That’s one thing that many in Martin County seem to agree on — that the residents are going to have to dig in and keep working to fix the water problems here.

Maynard is doing just that, by, among other things, running for local government. She says she is committed to staying in Martin County, where her roots go back six generations.

At the family cemetery, tucked behind a coal mine, there are dozens of graves, adorned with brightly colored flowers and ribbons. She walks carefully between the headstones, pointing out her grandparents and her cousins.

She stops at a tall headstone, piled high with flowers.

“Back here is my mommy, and hers is the prettiest, most fancy one here,” she says.

Maynard points down the sloping hill to a corner under a tree. “And I wanna be down there by that rock. Daddy will be right there. My kids will be right there.”

She looks around.

“There’s no price tag you can put on that,” she says.

Maureen Pao edited the Web story. Jolie Myers edited the audio story.



SOUTH FLORIDA AWASH IN COW MANURE State Allows Massive Animal Waste Discharges to Surface and Ground Waters


Manatee death from red tide (

Tallahassee — As South Florida waters suffer new outbreaks of both toxic red tides and blue-green algae blooms, a major aggravating factor receives little attention – the rising tide of cow manure and liquid wastes from concentrated animal feeding operations in the region, according to a new analysis released today by Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER).  Florida’s permitting system for these CAFOs is so lax that it facilitates huge amounts of nitrogen and phosphorus reaching its waters without any meaningful check or consequences.

The PEER analysis looks at 31 CAFO permits that the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) has issued in the seven-county area south of Orlando, with most in Okeechobee County directly to the north of Lake Okeechobee. These facilities hold approximately 90,000 dairy cows producing nearly two billion pounds of manure per year and more than 10 milliongallons of wastewater each day. The PEER analysis breaks down the ultimate destination of this huge waste stream.

“There is far greater focus on the massive discharges of nutrient-laden water from Lake O than on how these nutrients ended up there in the first place,” stated Florida PEER Director Jerry Phillips, a former DEP enforcement attorney, pointing out that just these 31 CAFOs annually generate net amounts in excess of 20 million pounds of nitrogen and 7.5 million pounds of phosphorous available for discharge into the environment.  “Despite obviously large impacts, Florida officially presumes that these CAFOs are not a source of pollution through a special brand of regulatory wishful thinking.”


Concentrated animal feeding operation (Wiki Image, 2007)

The DEP permit system merely asks CAFOs to follow management practices and to report the amount of waste applied but does not look at where the wastes ultimately go.  In addition, the state permits –

  • Allow CAFOs to build and operatewaste management systems that fail in major storm events, e.g. hurricanes and floods, knowing that they will not be held liable for pollution during these events;
  • Contain few safeguards against groundwater contamination. None of the permits set specific limits on the amount of fecal coliform, nitrogen, phosphorus, ortho phosphate, or turbidity that may enter the groundwater; and
  • Rely on CAFO best management practices that are often “suggested” rather than mandatory. Words such as “should” are frequently used, leaving pollution control as largely aspirational in nature, with permit conditions that are typically unenforceable.

“Florida’s CAFO permitsdo not tell the DEP, or the public, the volume of contaminates each facility is discharging each month,” added Phillips, noting that there have been only 5 enforcement actions taken by the DEP against these facilities and that all but one of them were over a decade old.  “The cumulative effects of this ongoing, unabated pollution burden on Florida’s waters is now taking an undeniable toll, prompting state of emergency declarations. It is not just the chickens, but the dairy cows too. that are coming home to roost.”




Skincare Chemical Threatens Coral Reefs

Common chemical is used in thousands of products to protect against harmful effects of ultraviolet light.

sunscreen-beachScientists have discovered that a common chemical used to protect against the damaging effects of ultraviolet light is highly toxic to juvenile corals and other marine life.


For more information from the site:

Since this report there have been found to be three major chemicals in sunscreens that affect coral reefs.  Please Google reef friendly sunscreens BEFORE you slather up and jump in the water:



Water Warning in Lee County

Cyanobacteria Lake O 6.2018NOAA satellite images showing progression of cyanobacteria in Lake Okeechobee, from June 12 to June 24, 2018.
unnamed (1)
There is never a good time for bad water quality but summer holidays make it critical that we get the word out.
A blue-green algae bloom that covers a majority of Lake Okeechobee and miles of river and estuary has tested positive for toxins. Please avoid contact with green water. Boating through blooms can release toxins. Do not eat fish caught in green water. Pets and livestock should also stay out of green water.
The Florida Poison Information Centers are available 24/7 365 days per year to answer questions related to health issues from harmful algal blooms, including cyanobacteria. Their toll-free number is 1-800-222-1222.
The Lee County Dept of Health issued the following warning:
unnamed (1)Lee County, Fla. – The Florida Department of Health in Lee County (DOH) is issuing a health advisory for the Alva Boat Ramp, Davis Boat Ramp, and Franklin Locks based on water sampling results from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP). DEP conducted sampling in the area and
found the presence of Cyanobacteria, commonly known as blue-green algae. When algae is visible, DOH recommends individuals using the boat ramp avoid contact with the water. DEP will continue to monitor the Alva Boat Ramp, Davis Boat Ramp, and Franklin Locks and post updates on their website.
Blue-green algae can cause gastrointestinal effects if swallowed. Children and pets are especially vulnerable, so keeping them away from the water during a bloom is especially important. Additional information on blue-green algae is available here. If you spot blue-green algae, please contact Kalina Warren, environmental administrator with DEP’s Water Quality Assessment Program for the South Region at 407-897-4177.
Florida Department of Health in Lee County
FOR MORE INFORMATION FROM SOURCE:  Sanibel Captiva Conservation Foundation | 3333 Sanibel Captiva RoadSanibel, FL 33957

Florida Legislators OK Plan to Dump Sewage Into Drinking-Water Aquifers

Screen Shot 2018-03-14 at 9.08.05 AM

Miamians get nearly all of their drinking water from the Biscayne Aquifer, a clean source of natural H2O that stretches underground from the southern tip of the state north to Palm Beach County. This being Florida, developers, utility companies, and scammers of all stripes are constantly devising new and ingenious ways to contaminate the aquifer. The water system already faces serious threats from sea-level rise and saltwater leaking from Florida Power & Light’s Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station.

Now the state Legislature has decided to allow companies to dump “treated” sewage into drinking-water sources.




Once again, students from Oxbridge Academy beat out the college students to win research prizes for their independent studies regarding water health and community


investment.  Studies ranged among:  fishing waste, fisherman attitudes towards bait management, St. Lucie River Estuary Algal plumes, edible plastics for bait bags, septic system effects on local beaches, and the effects of sunscreens on our coral reefs.  Well Done you amazing young people!


For more info:



Martina was the first high school student to ever win first place!  She was working on sunscreens, their effects on coral reefs, and consumer awareness.  She’s a SUPERSTAR!Screen Shot 2018-02-16 at 8.03.06 AMoxbridgeacademy  Congrats to Martina Cavard on winning the poster contest in the American Water Resources Association Annual (AWRA) Conference held in Oregon! Oxbridge was the only high school at the conference and Martina competed against undergraduate and graduate students for this award. Well done Martina!